たらどうですか vs ほうがいいです – Should in Japanese

When you’re learning Japanese, one useful skill is knowing how to give advice or suggestions. For example:

  • “You should study more.”
  • “Why don’t you take a break?”

In Japanese, two of the most natural ways to give advice are:

  • 〜たらどうですか
  • 〜ほうがいいです

At first, they might seem similar, but they have different tones and uses. In this post, we’ll break down the meaning, grammar, usage, and examples to help you master both.

🧩 What Does 〜たらどうですか Mean?

Meaning:

“How about doing…?” or “Why don’t you…?”
This is a soft and indirect way to give advice or a suggestion. It’s often used in daily conversation and sounds gentle and polite.

Structure:

→ た-form of verb + らどうですか

This is the polite form, but it also has casual variations:

  • 〜たらどう? → Casual, often used with friends
  • 〜たら? → Very casual and shortened, like a quick suggestion

You can choose based on the level of formality:

LevelExpressionExample
Polite〜たらどうですか病院びょういんったらどうですか? (How about going to the hospital?)
Casual〜たらどう?もうすこたらどう? (Why don’t you sleep a little more?)
Very casual〜たら?かあさんにいたら? (Why don’t you ask your mom?)

💡 Use this when giving light advice or friendly suggestions, especially when you don’t want to sound too direct.

📌 What Does 〜ほうがいいです Mean?

Meaning:

“You’d better…” or “You should…”
This is a stronger and more direct way to give advice, often based on logic, experience, or common sense.

Structure:

→ Verb in た-form + ほうがいいです
→ For negative advice: ない-form + ほうがいいです

Example Sentences:

  • くすりんだほうがいいですよ。
    You should take some medicine.
  • もっと勉強べんきょうしたほうがいいです。
    You’d better study more.
  • 夜遅くまでテレビをみないほうがいいですよ。
    You shouldn’t watch TV until late..

⚠️ Be careful when using this with someone older or in formal settings—it can sound too direct if not softened.

🔍 What’s the Difference?

Point〜たらどうですか〜ほうがいいです
🌱 ToneSofter, more casual suggestionStronger, firmer advice
💬 Nuance“Why don’t you try…?”“You should…” / “You’d better…”
👥 Use withFriends, equals, light suggestionsSerious advice, close friends
🔊 Casual form〜たら? / 〜たらどう?〜ほうがいいよ

📝 Practice Time

Try making your own advice sentences with the right form!

Your friend looks tired. Suggest resting a bit.
→ すこしやすん____。

Your classmate never studies. Give strong advice.
→ もっと勉強べんきょう__________。

Your friend told you they have a stomachache. Give strong advice to take a medicine.
→ おなかがいたいなら、くすりを_______________。

If you’re tired, why don’t you go to bed early?
つかれているなら、はやたらどう?

Your mom is coughing, kindly suggest her to go to the hospital.
せきがるなら、病院びょういんに____________?

Give a strong advice to your friend to get exercise everyday.
毎日まいにち_____________とおもうよ。

Give a strong suggestion to your classmate to review before the exam.
テストのまえに、______________?

🎯 In Summary

Both 〜たらどうですか and 〜ほうがいいです are used to suggest or recommend something. But the key difference is how strong your advice sounds:

  • ✅ Use 〜たらどうですか for friendly, soft suggestions
  • ✅ Use 〜ほうがいいです for firm, strong recommendations

Mastering the difference will make your Japanese sound more natural and help you communicate with the right tone!hen explaining how you feel or asking someone what’s going on!

If you want to learn Japanese, improve your skills, or connect with native speakers and other learners, we can help. We offer one-on-one lessons, a supportive community, and on demand courses.

Website: nihongonana.com
Email: support@nihongonana.com

Book 1-on-1 lessons: https://nihongonana.com/lessons/
✅Join our Speaking Club: https://nihongonana.com/community/
Join our Course Waitlist: https://nihongonana.com/courses/

Leave Comment